25+ Pros And Cons Of 401K Plan (Explained)

A 401 k plan is the retirement savings plan put forward by most American employers which give tax advantages to the saver. It is known as the 401K plan after the section of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code.

The employee who accepts a 401k agrees to have a percentage of each salary credited directly into an investment account. It is a prominent option among US citizens for savings for their retirement. 

Though works in the same way like other types of tax-saving retirement-focused accounts, there are many benefits, features, and rules for this plan which differ from other retirement planning type accounts.

Some key difference includes the withdrawal rules, contribution limits, and scope for employer matching contributions spotlight 401k plans mostly used in the world of retirement planning.

Advantages of 401K PlanDisadvantages of 401K Plan
Having federal legal protectionCumbersome for employer to establish
Getting free investing adviceStrict regulation
Tax advantagesOne May End Up Paying More in Taxes
Employee is in controlIt is based on assumption
One can take it with themContributions Follow a Schedule 
Easy payroll deductions

Advantages of 401K Plan

Having federal legal protection

Specific workplace retirement saving plans are safeguarded by the federal law “Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974”. It establishes a benchmark for the administrators who manage them and employers who offer retirement plans.

It offers retirement plans in employment a strong benefit that is recondite protection from creditors.

It came as law to protect employees and their survivor interests in workplace retirement plans like the process to claims and appeals, disclosure of key facts, features, and funding, the Right to sue for breaches, and benefits of fiduciary duty if the plan is not managed properly, Payment of benefits if one loses their job or a plan gets terminated.

Getting free investing advice

After an employee go for this workplace retirement plan, they must select from a menu of investment and savings options. Many plan providers are big brokerages like Fidelity or Vanguard and have helpful tools and enablers like free advisors and online assessments.

One gets the opportunity to get tailor-made advice well suited to their risk appetite for selecting the best investments. Generally one should invest more in stock funds if they have more time until retirement, or they have higher risk tolerance.

Similarly should own more low-risk and stable investments like bonds or money market funds if they have less time for their retirement or have a low tolerance for risk.

Tax advantages

Contributions made to a traditional 401k plan are directly taken out of wages earned before federal income taxes are accounted for.

As the contributions are deducted before tax is calculated, it lowers total taxable income which means one may pay less in income taxes, irrespective of whether one takes the standard deduction or itemize.

It can even place one in a lower tax slab.  The pre-tax contribution of employees is then tax-deferred till they choose to withdraw it for retirement. The reason is that post-retirement one will likely be in a comparatively lower tax bracket than they are taxed on the salary now.

The employee is in control

One can select to increase or decrease their contribution as per their financial position to their account however it is subject to plan and IRS limits.

Moreover, one has the flexibility to vary their contribution levels at any point of time depending on their situation subjective to plan limits.

The earlier one starts investing the more time their money has to grow. The most prominent advantage of investing in a 401k early is the compounding of interest. Compound interest is when one earns interest on the principal of investment with accumulated interest, that is one earns interest on interest.

Compounding has a big effect on long-term investment and is usually a powerful tool when it comes to planning for retirement. Apparently it may not appear like much looking at their 401k in their initial days but compounding does add up.

One can take it with them

Even if one changes their jobs, the sum they have contributed to their 401k and interest earned on it also belongs to them. Depending on their plan type, different options are available to keep their retirement plan invested and growing on a tax-deferred basis.

If they have left a company, but still have their old 401k with them, they have their options are for leaving it in plan or moving it to somewhere else.

Easy payroll deductions

If one start to invest early and contribute consistently as it is essential to establish their retirement plan. With a 401k one may set auto contributions directly from their salary. This makes saving an effortless and simple process.

And as the deduction is done before one gets salary credit, they will not have to bear the tax.

Disadvantages of 401K Plan

Cumbersome for employer to establish

The biggest disadvantage is the amount of time and money required to sponsor the 401K plan for employers. They are cumbersome to administer and set up. There are also costs for outsourcing the record-keeping, investments, and administration.

Moreover, companies, in general, have to pay specialists to manage the program’s initial establishment. 

Strict regulation

The major disadvantage is the strict regulations as this is under 401k section. 401k benefit plans are governed by the Department of Labor and the IRS. The regulations and rules set forth by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) are complex.

They require annual compliance testing. Compliance has become a liability for businesses that do not follow regulations.

One May End Up Paying More in Taxes

The big appeal of 401(k) plans apparently is that it acts as tax shelters. As long as one keeps the money idle, they do not owe taxes on the funds they contribute to this plan, and they do not owe taxes on any gains.

Yet one will have to pay taxes once one retires and begin to do withdrawals from their account. They will owe income tax on their contributions and on their gains.

So if one earns a higher wage when they retire than when they made contributions, one will be in a higher tax bracket.

Consequently, they will owe more than if they had not deferred their taxes. In turn, if their tax bracket places them at a higher tax rate than the long-term capital gains tax rate depending on their income under this tax law one will pay more in taxes.

It is based on assumption

It is based on assumption that people will earn less when they will stop working as their only income will be from the investments made by them and Social Security. But there are people who had been earning may earn more post their retirement.

Professionals that are smart in investing and saving in turn earn a higher income when they retire.

If one is an entry-level or a superstar saver they are forced to consider a Roth IRA or see if their company offers a Roth 401k. With these savings plans, one has to pay income taxes upfront on their contributions and no taxes on any gains when one retire.

Contributions Follow a Schedule 

401k has inherent that it follows a Schedule regardless of market conditions. Though, one should never try to time the market.

Top experts say it is because rule of cost averaging. The hypothesis is that if one steadily invests small amounts during the time the market is on lows, highs and plateaus, one will ultimately pay less for all of their investments than if they tried to buy only at the lows.

It is partially based on the fact that one does not know a bottom until it has occurred. In fact most people do not have time to observe the market nor has discipline to set aside money for later use

Similar Posts:

Was this article helpful?

Did you like this article? Why not share it:

Leave a Comment